Press Release
August 12, 2025

City of Phoenix Pulls Out of Malicious Prosecution Settlement With Nubia Rodriguez, Woman Wrongly Charged for Officer's Accidental Death

On March 21, 2019, Nubia Rodriguez hit Officer Paul Rutherford in the two-way turn lane on Indian School Road near 75th Avenue.

For more than three years, officials tried to prosecute her for the tragic death of Officer Paul Rutherford, with police and prosecutors withholding key video evidence and using misleading and biased testimony to obtain a negligent homicide charge.

“The City of Phoenix's treatment of Nubia Rodriguez remains, in a word, abhorrent.  The City falsely accused Nubia of the homicide of a police officer who, by all accounts, was a good man who made a tragic mistake by running into traffic.  The city refuses to take accountability for its officers' actions and the absolute destruction of an innocent woman's life.”

Larry WulkanAttorney Representing Nubia Rodriguez

Read the full article at ABC15 Arizona

Larry J. Wulkan

Larry Wulkan’s practice concentrates on three areas: general civil and commercial litigation, civil rights litigation, and catastrophic injury litigation.  He focuses on large, complicated cases with many moving parts.

Related People

Related Services